Posted by admin on March 10, 2010

Nostalgia Critic – LOTR Animated vs LOTR (Part 1)

I Am Not Nostalgia Critic!!! Not Made By Me!!! Full Credit To: www.thatguywiththeglasses.com

Post a Comment


25 Responses to “Nostalgia Critic – LOTR Animated vs LOTR (Part 1)”

  1. bioo80 says:

    I have never saw either vut if i have i would have trouble choosing

  2. thenewguy303 says:

    5:18
    “you cant trust let you face trouble alone, and go off without a word… were your freinds frodo”
    “well thank you pippin”
    “im merry”
    ” whatever your all short”
    rofl

  3. mets2128 says:

    could some one get this guy to do old vs. new Iron Chef Japan vs. Iron Chef America

  4. LetsPlayGuy12 says:

    sometime, could you do a old vs. new with the alice in wonderland thing? i just watched it yesterdat, and i would like to know your opinion about wich one wins out.

  5. sunlexlo says:

    that’s because they used rotoscoping

  6. Dinosaurboy123 says:

    Why the fuck does Frodo’s voice in the animated version make him sound like a pussy?!

  7. Kingnothing8585 says:

    @Segador128
    Yeah, it reminds of of those (I Think) 40’s/50’s Superman cartoon’s. It looked so human that it creeped the hell out of me.

  8. 15Anime4Ever15 says:

    I’ve never read the books or seen the movies. I’m purely watching this ’cause NC is so fun to watch. XD

  9. MrMatto91 says:

    Jacksons Lotrs all the way.
    it had great acting
    it had great music

    i thought Bakshi’s Sam was f*cked up too

  10. Segador128 says:

    The movement in the animation is so life like.

  11. Alexansu11 says:

    Yes, an Obama joke
    7:15

  12. spiffy143 says:

    7:41 he he he thank you

  13. speedyhobbit says:

    THANK YOU! The Jackson Frodo is a frikkin’ pansy!

  14. MSKDphantom says:

    aragorn’s voice doesn’t really match his character in the animated movie

  15. RedGroundBlackSnake says:

    I think it was a misinterpretation of the idea that the Morgul Blade would turn its victim into an undead wraith,but not a Ringwraith.

  16. ugotrickrlled says:

    The coca-cola bit was hillarious! XD

  17. awexsome2034 says:

    I gotta disagree on the Aragon ruling for two reasons.

    One- That kingly feeling that Aragorn has doesn’t really shine til’ the third movie. And rightly so since that is the movie where he has to deal with it more than any other.

    Two- Did you see how they looked? I mean most of the cartoon’s versions looked just fine in cartoon form but… Aragorn was just plain UGLY.

  18. PrivateIrishmayne says:

    This guy is a fucking GOON

  19. DemonDante147 says:

    but you draw cartoons and voice them actors ACT the whole thing so tell me which ends up better?

  20. fluffysbro says:

    They’re both films. The Bashki LOTR is just an animated film.

  21. DemonDante147 says:

    how can you compare a cartoon to a film honestly . . . meh

  22. manofria84 says:

    now I want to watch the animated version

  23. bracek1 says:

    You misspelled Baskhi

  24. ZeldaQueen64 says:

    I saw the Bashki version after Jackson’s FOTR came out. I had no idea what was going on half of the time.

  25. tolchok89 says:

    @godzilla964 Yeah, or The Shining – Kubrick’s 1980 film vs. the 1997 miniseries. And we all know which one is gonna win.

Leave a Reply